Email: Today's Business Convenience...Tomorrow’s Legal Nightmare
By Veronica
Valentine McNally
If you
are like most people, you use email daily. You use it to let your secretary
know about an event that needs calendaring, to send a note to colleagues, or to
notify clients of the latest and greatest widget. It is a business convenience.
Unfortunately, today's business convenience has the potential to become
tomorrow's legal nightmare.
People view email as causal, inconsequential and easily deleted correspondence;
when, in fact, the opposite is true. In the legal word, email is discoverable, i.e. subject to review by the opposing
side. It is a minefield. Once litigation
commences, the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure require organizations to
locate, preserve, and produce electronically stored information, such as email
that may be relevant to a particular case, quickly, accurately, and
comprehensively. Also, you may be required to preserve all relevant electronic
files in anticipation of litigation.
Even before litigation commences, your email correspondence could be
scrutinized. In 2006, in an attempt to uncover her source in a media link, HP “bugged”
email sent to Dawn Kawamoto of CNETnews.com. It utilized the service of a company called
ReadyNoftify. The tracking mechanism provided by ReadyNotify allowed
investigators to see who opened a file attached to an email. The objective was
to determine whether Kawamoto forwarded email to her source to determine who
was leaking HP confidential information.[i]
Consider also the recent Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations
Hearing where Senator Carl Levin confronted Goldman Sach's, Dan Sparks, about
his company's email correspondence regarding an investment. The email stated,
"'boy that Timberwolf was one shitty deal." Levin inquired how much
of that "shitty deal" Goldman Sachs continued to sell to its clients.[ii] Should you cease using email correspondence
as part of your business routine? No. Should you get smarter about your use?
Absolutely. Follow these five simple rules.
Rule No. 1
Use Email Less Frequently
We live
in a tech world -- so much so that the younger generations actually think LOL
is part of the English language. While it is often much quicker to send an
email from our iPhones and BlackBerrys rather than make a phone call, recognize
that sometimes it is better just to make that call. Consider all of the things
that can go awry in sending an email: it could be sent to the wrong recipient
or attach the wrong document. And,
frankly, even more dangerous is the fact that things are often stated in emails
that probably would not be stated in other correspondence. And, let’s not
forget the knee-jerk reaction that many have when it comes to replying to
emails. So, use it less frequently.
Rule No. 2
Establish An Email Policy For Your Employees
Do you
know what your employees are doing when it comes to email correspondence? Are
they forwarding jokes, archiving emails; or even creating binding contracts
without your knowledge? The fact is employees may be doing things that are
against your business interest. Prevention is the best medicine. Your policy
should cover the following basics:
- Email should be professional and
courteous.
- Email must not contain any
illegal, libelous, or offensive statements.
- Email is for business purposes,
not for personal use.
- All email is company property.
- The company has the right to
access email sent to or from every computer.
- The company has the right to
retrieve email stored on its servers that users have deleted from their email
programs.
- Employees who violate the email
policy will be subject to disciplinary measures or termination.
Rule No. 3
Keep Business Correspondence Separate From Personal Correspondence
The
independent research firm of Osterman Research conducted a study of mid to
large sized U.S.
corporations, called the MessageOne Study.
The purpose of the study was to learn about employees' individual email
usage habits and patterns. What was discovered was this startling fact: the
average employee sends and receives an average of 170 emails per day at work
and that nearly a third of the respondents use their personal email accounts
(e.g. AOL, Yahoo mail, Hot Mail etc.) for business purposes at least twice a
week. Even more startling is the fact that 17% of the respondents use their
personal email accounts for business every day.[iii] And, it appears no one is immune. Remember the Sarah Palin email debacle? She
used personal email for business correspondence in the Troopergate scandal.[iv] While personal correspondence
may still be discoverable during litigation, a better case can be made to
prevent disclosure of personal email correspondence if it is not used for
business correspondence.
Rule No. 4
In Business Correspondence, Write As If You Were Sending A Formal
Business Letter
If your
email is subject to review during litigation, it will be far less embarrassing
if it is written in a formal tone, with proper grammar and punctuation. Recall
the Goldman Sachs' email. Need anything further be said?
Rule No. 5
Clean The Metadata Before You Send Attachments
Last but
not least, if you decide to send a document via email, be sure to clean the
metadata first. Metadata is data about data. Metadata is the information behind
the words; it is information about the history, tracking or management of an
electronic document. Failure to appreciate its importance could be detrimental
to your business. Microsoft word
and all
similar file formats have methods by which you can clean the metadata. There
are also programs you can install that will scan your documents before you send
them. When all else fails, send a hard copy.
Bottom line – in today’s world it is impossible
to avoid email. It is not, however,
impossible to avoid using email recklessly and in a manner that might cause you
and/or your company irreparable damages.
Remember the Five Rules:
- Use
email as infrequently as possible.
- Establish
an email policy for your employees (one that you follow as well!).
- Keep
business correspondence separate from personal correspondence.
- In
business correspondence write as if you are sending a formal business
letter; and
- Clean
the metadata before you send attachments.
Following these five simple rules cannot hurt
and they could make a positive difference further down the road.
[i] (http://news.cnet.com/How-HP-bugged-e-mail/2100-1029_3-6121048.html,
last visited on 4/30/10).
[ii] (http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-503544_162-20003526-503544.html,
last visited 4/30/10).
[iii] (http://reno.injuryboard.com/defective-and-dangerous-products/personal-email-may-be-discoverable.aspx?googleid=224474,
last visited on 4/30/10).
[iv] http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2008/09/palins-e-mail-habits-come-under-fire.ars, last visited on 4/30/10).
May 2010
Valentine & Associates, P.C. – West Bloomfield, MI
Copyright 2010